Health and safety forum
Insect repellent - anything 100% effective?
Have questions? Jump to our menu of forum quicklinks
Add your reply
You need to be logged in to add a reply.
Not a member? you can join here.
| Possibly related discussions | Replies | Views | Latest reply |
|---|---|---|---|
| insect and midge repellent ... By komal1290 on 24 Jun 2011 | 0 | 2124 | 24 Jun 2011 |
| insect repellent issues... ... By jack2408 on 15 Feb 2010 | 6 | 4781 | 23 Feb 2010 |
| incognito insect repellent ... By Puzzle on 3 Sep 2010 | 0 | 1466 | 3 Sep 2010 |
| Natural insect repellent. ... By nerja on 6 Nov 2011 | 4 | 1453 | 6 Nov 2011 |

jemal29
Joined Travelfish
24th September, 2012
Posts 3
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
Hi all,
I'm off to travel round Thailand in a few weeks to escape this miserable UK weather, and I'm feeling rather paranoid about getting bitting by mosquitos. I know insect repellent has been discussed here before, but they've concentrated mainly on natural repellents - I want something that's going to be as close to 100% effective as possible even if it is some chemical-rich concoction.
So, has anyone here ever used an insect repellent and never got bitten? I know I haven't!
Cheers,
J
#1 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 16:21
busylizzy
Joined Travelfish
31st December, 2007
Location New Zealand
Posts 1873
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
If you don't mind the chemicals, then use Deet - get the highest % content that you can find. It's horrible stuff though - thick and sticky. Otherwise, just cover up (socks, long trousers, long shirt).
#2 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 17:28
------------------------------
As you grow older, you'll find the only things you regret are the things you didn't do.
Advertisement
somsai
Joined Travelfish
1st March, 2006
Location United States
Posts 541
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Tiny dabs of Deet on collars or back of hands etc. work like magic. Never seen anything as good. The chemicals in it are as worrisome to me as, well, absolutely don't even register. Probably a thousand times better than those smoke coils everyone uses in their rooms.
#3 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 18:27
altmtl
Joined Travelfish
18th May, 2009
Location Earth
Posts 765
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
I use citronella based products, but I'm not paranoid about getting bitten, it doesn't really bother me all that much. You can use coils in your room and a net.
#4 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 21:10
altmtl's social networks[Twitter] [Facebook]
------------------------------
Join the FB Group: South East Asia 2013 - Travel buddies and more...
MADMAC
Joined Travelfish
6th June, 2009
Posts 5072
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
Don't wear shorts or open toed footwear, especially evenings, and you should be good to hook. Most of us anglos have hair on our arms which offers natural protection. I have lived here five years and can count on one hand the number of times I was bitten.
#5 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 21:50
------------------------------
Victory in Pattani
altmtl
Joined Travelfish
18th May, 2009
Location Earth
Posts 765
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
yeah, but look where live - lol - hardly an issue in Issam I found
#6 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 21:55
altmtl's social networks[Twitter] [Facebook]
------------------------------
Join the FB Group: South East Asia 2013 - Travel buddies and more...
tyler
Joined Travelfish
7th December, 2010
Location Canada
Posts 199
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
I usually just wear long pants/shirt. Sometimes - depending where I am - I'll use Citronella. It works well for me. And it doesn't smell like deet or bother my skin. But the mossy's only tend to be an issue at night anyway.
100% - stay inside!
#7 Posted: 24/9/2012 - 23:03
busylizzy
Joined Travelfish
31st December, 2007
Location New Zealand
Posts 1873
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
"Most of us anglos have hair on our arms which offers natural protection."

Well, that won't work for those of us who shave our legs!
#8 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 00:28
------------------------------
As you grow older, you'll find the only things you regret are the things you didn't do.
travellings-
arah
TF writer
Joined Travelfish
23rd March, 2010
Location Vietnam
Posts 563
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Is that why I never get bites on my arms even when my legs are being bitten to shreds? Hmmm, time to stop shaving I think. Anyway, in response to original question - agree that Deet is the ultimate but there's a really cheap product called Soffell here in Vietnam and it seems to work really well. It's available in Thailand too. http://www.enesis.com/product/detail/en/5
#9 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 00:39
------------------------------
www.supportcarlbart.com
SBE
Joined Travelfish
14th April, 2008
Location Global Village
Posts 1793
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Lemon eucalyptus extract is as effective and as long lasting as DEET according to this expert review of insect repellents.
The principal repellent component of lemon eucalyptus extract is PMD, which is the main by-product of lemon eucalyptus hydrodistillation.43 The active component is prepared through acid modified extraction of leaves or a synthetic version of PMD is used in the majority of commercially available preparations. Importantly, PMD has been proven to prevent malaria in a clinical trial in the Bolivian Amazon.44
Studies carried out both in the laboratory and the field using rigorous methodology have shown PMD to be a repellent of equal efficacy and longevity as deet.45 At 30% AI, PMD provided almost complete protection for 4 hours in South America46 and complete protection for 6 hours at 50% AI in Sub-Saharan Africa against malaria vectors.47 In both of these studies, the protection time was equivalent to the deet controls. A well-designed laboratory trial of PMD against a further African malaria vector showed complete protection for 4 to 5 hours using PMD impregnated towlettes,48 again comparable with deet. Laboratory trials using the main vectors of dengue fever have shown good protection, which is important for travelers as the vector bites in the day-time.45,49 Against the tick vectors of Lyme disease and Rocky Mountain spotted fever, PMD reduces attachment and feeding success by around 77%, and PMD is highly effective against the Highland Midge.50 PMD has not been tested against the vectors of leishhmaniasis in vivo, although in vitro results suggest that it may be effective.51
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1708-8305.2010.00402.x/full
#10 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 02:31
Advertisement
jemal29
Joined Travelfish
24th September, 2012
Posts 3
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
Wow, thanks guys. A quick google using the search words "deet insect repellent" brought up some useful results, but it looks like the strongest is "100+", and I'm sure I've used that one before...and still got bit. Oh well, I'll take some of your tips on board and perhaps I'll bring a citronella-based repellent as well as deet, as it looks like they both do a similar job.
Cheers!
#11 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 16:07
MADMAC
Joined Travelfish
6th June, 2009
Posts 5072
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
Jemal, just remmember, if the skin is covered up, the mosquito can't get to it. So if you wear shoes instead of sandals, and long pants intead of shorts, the mosquitos area of attack is much more limited, making for easier defense.
#12 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 21:45
------------------------------
Victory in Pattani
altmtl
Joined Travelfish
18th May, 2009
Location Earth
Posts 765
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Funny thing is I'm usually semi nude on the beach and in my room - clothes are so restricting.
#13 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 22:04
altmtl's social networks[Twitter] [Facebook]
------------------------------
Join the FB Group: South East Asia 2013 - Travel buddies and more...
MADMAC
Joined Travelfish
6th June, 2009
Posts 5072
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
I don't do the beach, and I don't have skeeters in my room. So I'm good to go. My wife is always comlaining about getting bit - because she likes to wear dresses and shorts...
#14 Posted: 25/9/2012 - 23:15
------------------------------
Victory in Pattani
busylizzy
Joined Travelfish
31st December, 2007
Location New Zealand
Posts 1873
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Tell her not to shave her legs, Mac, and she'll have natural protection!
#15 Posted: 26/9/2012 - 03:12
------------------------------
As you grow older, you'll find the only things you regret are the things you didn't do.
MADMAC
Joined Travelfish
6th June, 2009
Posts 5072
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
She's Thai. She has a really small amount of natural body hair. She's screwed.
#16 Posted: 26/9/2012 - 07:24
------------------------------
Victory in Pattani
SBE
Joined Travelfish
14th April, 2008
Location Global Village
Posts 1793
Member profile
Profile page
Private message
Adolescent Thai girls wearing frumpy high school uniforms often have a great deal of leg hair.
Perhaps it all naturally falls off as soon as they hit 18.
#17 Posted: 26/9/2012 - 08:09
MADMAC
Joined Travelfish
6th June, 2009
Posts 5072
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
I don't know SBE. My wife doesn't shave her legs and she doesn't have any hair on them - or almost none. Certainly not enough to help her with the mosquito problem! I personally can't speak for all adolescent Thai girls.
#18 Posted: 26/9/2012 - 22:11
------------------------------
Victory in Pattani
Xircal
Joined Travelfish
24th December, 2012
Posts 57
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
I use DEET bought from a local drug store. You can buy it in Thailand provided you're in a tourist area like Bangkok or Phuket, but once you're out in the sticks, you'll be lucky if you can find any. Or at least, that has been my experience.
Some tips though. Mozzies like to bite where your skin is the thinnest and ankles are a favourite.
I was able to find DEET in an aerosol can in Thailand which also worked upside down. It's called "Off!" and is available in most Big C supermarkets. But it's pretty strong stuff and my skin began to wrinkle wthin a couple of days of using it. I never got bitten though. Here are some pix of it: http://is.gd/fFv2WV
#19 Posted: 1/1/2013 - 09:20
PaulWhite
Joined Travelfish
8th January, 2013
Posts 3
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
In different kind of place their is always a lotion for insect bite that 100 percent effective.
#20 Posted: 8/1/2013 - 05:52
JaiYen88
Joined Travelfish
25th April, 2012
Posts 54
Member profile
Profile private
Messaging not enabled.
I've been using a mixture of pure citronella oil diluted in baby oil, about 4 parts baby oil to 1 part citronella. I find it to be quite effective as long as you reapply every hour or two. All you need is a thin coating on whatever bits of skin are exposed. The downsides are that you always have to take a shower before bed because you are quite greasy by the end of the night and also some people (especially Lao and Isaan people for some reason) dislike the smell!
#21 Posted: 5/3/2013 - 11:15