Hanoi or Saigon?
First published 21st May, 2012
When I visited Vietnam's commercial capital of Ho Chi Minh City while travelling in 2009 I didn't warm to it. Possibly that was due to the bout of food poisoning I had been living with since Mui Ne, but I think there was more to it than that: it seemed to lack any charm or character, falling into the categories of 'business centre' and 'big city' rather than having any great tourist, or cultural, appeal.
So when it came to a decision about where to live, although I recognised the business opportunities that Ho Chi Minh City would offer, I opted for the capital, Hanoi. Over two years later I stand by that decision: for what Hanoi lacks in big business, transport links and nightlife it makes up for in an easily accessible expat network, an old-world ambiance and apartments overlooking the lake.
And if tourists ask for my opinion on which of the two to visit I also recommend Hanoi. Here is why.
Just another day in Hanoi.
Let's start with sights. Both have their fair share of museums, and indeed you could match like for like as both have a history museum, a war museum, a women's museum and so on. Hanoi's Ethnology Museum is a stand out option, as is the Temple of Literature, but then Hanoi doesn't have Reunification Palace. Both also have plenty of pagodas, churches and outdoor spaces.
However, Hanoi strides ahead in two areas: the Old Quarter and the lakes. The Old Quarter has the charm and character that HCMC lacks. Of course, this can be found down the alleys and away from the centre of the city in both, but the blend of traditional architecture and local life is readily accessible and intensely felt in the Old Quarter.
Motorbikes and narrow streets - Hanoi in a nutshell.
I've read comments before about Old Quarter just being for tourists. This was clearly written by someone who hasn't explored beyond the few central streets; I spend a lot of time wandering the streets of Old Quarter and local people are living their lives irrespective of the tourists who may, occasionally, wander past their home. It's a great place to get lost too - just walk, see something you like, turn into a tiny alley, stop for a coffee at a hole in the wall, people watch as you sip on an iced lemon tea... many happy days can be spent exploring.
Of course, you can explore in Ho Chi Minh, but it just doesn't match up. And let's compare Old Quarter with the Pham Ngu Lao area of Ho Chi Minh City, where most of the tourist life is concentrated. For me, this area of HCMC is closer to Thailand's Khao San Road (OK, so it's still not that close) than it is to Hanoi: it appears to be completely dedicated to tourism and is usually heaving with people taking advantage of the 10,000 VND Saigon beer. I'm not saying that's a bad thing -- hey, it's cheaper than bia Hanoi so who's complaining -- but there's something a bit tacky about the area. Although I must add that the fruit shakes available along Bui Vien for under a dollar are amazing.
Time to explore!
As for the lakes in Hanoi, they offer a real sense of space and life: the city would feel claustrophobic without them, and walking or cycling around West Lake, stopping for a coconut drink along its banks or watching the fishermen wait patiently for the day's catch is one of the pleasures of life in Hanoi.
Hoan Kiem lake provides a different experience, as its banks are more crowded and it's hard to escape the souvenir sellers, but it is still a delightful place for a walk or a rest with an ice cream.
Another sight that takes my breath away (metaphorically) every time I go past is the Mausoleum. Viewed across the park it is such a majestic sight. The Opera House and the Sofitel Metropole Legend Hotel evoke similar reactions.
I would also recommend Hanoi as a start point for anyone visiting Vietnam for just a short period of time. A holiday comprising time in Hanoi, Ha Long Bay and Sapa, with short trips to Tam Coc and Ba Vi if you've time, provides a wonderful breadth of experiences, all without excessive travelling.
Time for a sugar cane hit.
As for shopping, if you're after souvenirs, particularly lacquerwork and silk, then Hanoi has an abundance of outlets, all clustered within Old Quarter -- try the streets around Hang Gai and Hang Manh. Noteworthy outlets such as Craftlink and Tan My Design, as well as some wonderful boutique shops, are also located along Nha Tho, near the cathedral.
I'm not going to claim that Ho Chi Minh City doesn't have its advantages. If you're seeking a range of international cuisine, high-end bars and clubs or rowdy late night pubs, Ho Chi Minh is the place to be. It's enhanced the appeal of the city for me -- my now regular visits are planned around where I can go to eat and drink and I also love walking around the wide open streets between Hai Ba Trung and Nguyen Du in the evening -- but most people don't come to Vietnam for that.
And of course, Hanoi is not without its culinary delights. The street food is astounding in its variety and taste -- food in Ho Chi Minh City is also great but they use more sugar so it has a sweeter taste -- and high-end restaurants such as La Badiane serve up world class fare at less than world class prices. There's also a wide variety of cuisines available, including some excellent Japanese and Korean restaurants.
The other, little visited, Lakeside.
In summary, a lot of parallels between Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City can be drawn in terms of the tangibles -- the sights, the accommodation, the local life, the food -- and the difference lies mostly in the atmosphere, the lakes and the overall architecture of the cities. Hanoi throws visitors endless surprises and delights -- and sometimes frustrations -- and is worth more than a passing visit en route to the next stop.
Story by Sarah Turner
Related readingDo nothing and see the best of Hanoi
How to enjoy your time in Vietnam
One day in Hanoi
Street food safety
Read 5 comment(s)
Add your comment
Feature story quicklinks
- Giving back in Southeast Asia (10)
- All stories
- COPE: Helping people move on
- Helping Phuket's children in need
- Helping Siem Reap's rubbish dump families
- Helping Singapore's transient workers
- Helping the Karen of Burma
- Humanitarian Services for Children of Vietnam
- Lifestart Foundation, Hoi An
- Thai Freedom House, Chiang Mai
- The Samui Prison Project
- The SET Foundation
- Burma (6)
- Cambodia (21)
- All stories
- A Cambodian Eco-lodge
- A honeymoon in Cambodia
- Angkorian traffic woes
- Battambang weekend
- Elephant riding in Cambodia: Should you?
- Great places to stay in Siem Reap
- Is Preah Vihear safe to visit?
- Koh Rong: Trouble in paradise?
- Kompong Cham escape
- Northeast Cambodia in photos
- Oh Poipet!
- PEPY:Sustainable Cambodian tourism
- Phnom Tamao Wildlife Refuge
- Sihanoukville beaches lure expats
- Spas, shopping & seers in Siem Reap
- The best islands in Cambodia
- The best places to stay on Cambodia's islands
- The Death Highway
- Trekking the Cardamoms in Cambodia
- Which Cambodian island is right for you?
- Why you should go to Cambodia
- Indonesia (13)
- All stories
- A funeral in Toraja, Sulawesi
- Climbing Rinjani
- How to hire a boat in Indonesia: Without drowning
- Learn to surf in Bali
- Medewi: A great Bali getaway
- Mountain biking in Bali: A ride in the woods
- The Gili islands: Which is the right one for you?
- Ubud bird watching: From waterhens to witchcraft
- Ubud shopping guide
- Village trekking in Tana Toraja
- Weekend in Nusa Penida
- Yogya's student scene
- Laos (15)
- All stories
- Best budget rooms in Luang Prabang 2013
- Elephant trekking in Laos
- Exploring Laos' Bolaven Plateau
- Huay Xai to Pak Tha by slowboat
- Is Lao Airlines safe to fly?
- Laos' vanishing elephants
- Luang Prabang escape
- Muang Ngoi Escape
- Photos of Luang Prabang, Laos
- Pi Mai Lao in Luang Prabang: In 1999
- Southern Laos by scooter
- Temples in Luang Prabang
- The Gibbon Experience
- The Phonsavan adventure
- Vientiane's Chinatown
- Malaysia (6)
- Singapore (9)
- Thailand (70)
- All stories
- 10 Bangkok galleries worth a look-see
- 10 Thai treks aside from Chiang Mai
- 24 Hours in Bangkok: Sukhumvit to Siam Square
- 5 Southern Thai towns to lose time in
- A Thai homestay in Ayutthaya
- A weekend in Phra Phradaeng
- A weekend on Ko Samet, Thailand
- An extra day in Krabi
- Andaman Sea island hopper
- Ayutthaya temple tour
- Bangkok for art lovers
- Bangkok's Charoen Krung Road
- Bangkok's Thonburi: exploring the west side
- Brilliant Bangkok
- Chiang Dao getaway
- Chiang Mai's temples
- Corruption in Thailand
- Eating on the edge
- Elephant's World Kanchanaburi
- Exploring Lamphun
- Exploring the Lungs of Bangkok
- Far southern Thailand: Go or not?
- Floating markets around Bangkok
- Highlights of Chanthaburi province
- How to do Khao Yai National Park
- Khao San Road safety and scams
- Ko Mun Nork: a nearby paradise
- Ko Pha Ngan 7-day detox:Colonic fast
- Ko Pha Ngan's best beaches in 2013
- Ko Phi Phi on a budget
- Ko Tao for non-divers guide
- Ko Yao: the islands you're looking for
- Learning Muay Thai in Bangkok
- Motorcycling the Chiang Rai loop
- Narathiwat: residence of good people
- Navigating Bangkok: The BTS Skytrain
- Phuket by night
- Phuket for Kids
- Phuket heritage walk: Car parts to saris
- Phuket's secret beaches
- Planning around Thailand's civil unrest
- Roll your own Kanchanaburi
- Should I book for the full moon party?
- Should I cancel my Thai holiday? No.
- Soi Thong Lo, Bangkok
- Sorting out Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Staying at a Thai monastery
- Thai islands for nature lovers
- Thai islands to lose yourself on
- Thai visa FAQ
- Thailand tsunami wrap
- Thailand's Mae Khlong market
- Thailand: Where to from here?
- The best beach on Ko Samui
- The best places to stay on Ko Kut, Thailand
- The bridge over the River Kwai festival
- The road to Sangkhlaburi
- Travelling through north-east Thailand
- Trekking in Thailand
- Trisara -- decadent luxury at its best
- Two days in Kamphaeng Phet
- What is the best beach on Ko Tao?
- What is the best island in Thailand?
- What's a good beach on Ko Pha Ngan?
- What's a good beach on Ko Samui?
- Where to stay at Railay Bay, Thailand
- Where to stay in Sukhothai?
- Where to stay on Ko Samet, Thailand
- Which beach on Ko Samui?
- Which island in Trang?
- Vietnam (31)
- All stories
- A short break in Nha Trang
- A Weekend in Can Tho
- Being fed Fido: Eating dog in Vietnam
- Buying a touring motorbike in Vietnam
- Con Dao escape
- Do nothing and see the best of Hanoi
- Doing the DMZ from Hue
- Exploring Kon Tum
- Exploring Vietnam's Mekong Delta
- Ha Long Bay conclusions
- Ha Long Bay for backpackers
- Ha Long Bay for budget-busters
- Ha Long Bay for flashpackers
- Hanoi escape
- Hanoi or Saigon?
- Hoi An -- Walking over the dragon
- How to do the Dien Bien Phu loop
- How to enjoy your time in Vietnam
- How to pick a good Ha Long Bay cruise
- Is the Hoi An culture tour worth it?
- Motorbike Vietnam's Central Highlands
- One day in Hanoi
- Responsible shopping and eating in Hoi An
- Saigon's top 10 cafés
- Sapa or Bac Ha?
- Saving Vietnam's bears
- Street food safety
- The DMZ: Traveller tactical briefing
- Travel tips for Tet in Vietnam 2013
- Two Wheels & Ricefields: A review
- Which is the best street food tour in Hanoi?
- Accommodation guides (19)
- All stories
- 2005 Top guesthouses in Bangkok
- 2005 Top guesthouses in Chiang Mai
- 2006 Top guesthouses in Hanoi
- 2006 Top guesthouses in Phnom Penh
- 2006 Top guesthouses on Ko Phi Phi
- 2006 Top Luang Prabang guesthouses
- 2008 Top Bangkok airport guesthouses
- 2008 Top Luang Prabang guesthouses
- 2008 Top spots on Phu Quoc Island
- 2009 Top guesthouses in Bangkok
- 2009 Top Phnom Penh guesthouses
- 2011 Best places to stay in Kuala Lumpur
- 2011 Best places to stay on Ko Phi Phi
- Best places to stay in Hanoi 2012
- Cheap Phuket guesthouses & hotels
- Five special hotels in Cambodia
- Ko Lipe's best budget guesthouses 2012
- The changing face of Khao San Road
- Where to stay on Koh Rong Samloem
- Travel with kids (7)
- Opinion & advice (14)
- All stories
- 10 reasons to do an adventure tour
- 10 reasons to travel independently
- A year's worth of travel for 2013
- Beach hideaways in Asia
- Do I need reservations for my holiday?
- Evil man of Krabi
- Fifteen tips for a great holiday in Asia
- Getting a cheap airfare to Asia
- Hotels should never charge extra for WiFi
- Long distance buses in Southeast Asia
- Mass tourism in Southeast Asia
- Nine Asian upcountry hideaways
- Planning a Gap Year? Some advice.
- Ten Southeast Asian trips for 2008
- How do I? (11)
- All stories
- Bangkok to Ko Samui, Pha Ngan & Tao
- Bangkok to Siem Reap
- Catching a train in Thailand
- Catching a train in Vietnam
- Cheap flights with Discovery Airpass
- Chiang Mai to Luang Prabang
- Crossing the Cambodia Laos border
- Ko Chang to Phu Quoc Island
- Siem Reap to Ko Chang
- Stops between Bangkok & Chiang Mai
- Visa run from Thailand to Burma
- Cycling Asia (13)
- All stories
- 24 hours in Bangkok
- An Angkor cycling guide
- An introduction
- Battambang, bamboo trains & guides
- Confessions of a "cheating cyclist"
- Cycles of all sorts
- Ha Long Bay independently
- Ko Samet Vs Pattaya
- Muay Thai night
- Phonsavan and Luang Prabang
- The hills of Vietnam
- The road less travelled
- Tubing in Vang Vieng
- Health and safety (6)
- Money and finance (4)
- Diving guides (6)
- Photo essay (3)
- Guest blog (2)
- General (15)
- All stories
- 10 Christmas days in Asia we're yet to have
- 10 dumb things I've done while travelling
- 34 ways to travel greener
- Asian animal experiences
- Call me Mr Massage Magic
- Chefs Without Borders
- Flying is fun!
- Mr Golden
- On being a travel writer
- Teaching ESL in Asia
- The 211 country honeymoon
- The Boxing Day Tsunami: 5 years on.
- To Teach or Not to Teach
- Travel writing scholarship 2012
- Tuk to the Road Charity ride
- Book reviews (5)
- Interviews (8)
- Explore Bangkok by BTS (16)
- All stories
- Bangkok by skytrain: Ari
- Bangkok by skytrain: Chid Lom
- Bangkok by skytrain: Chong Nonsi
- Bangkok by skytrain: Mo Chit
- Bangkok by skytrain: National Stadium
- Bangkok by skytrain: On Nut
- Bangkok by skytrain: Phaya Thai
- Bangkok by skytrain: Phloen Chit
- Bangkok by skytrain: Phrom Phong
- Bangkok by skytrain: Ratchadamri
- Bangkok by skytrain: Ratchathewi
- Bangkok by skytrain: Sala Daeng (S2)
- Bangkok by skytrain: Sanam Pao
- Bangkok by skytrain: Saphan Taksin
- Bangkok by skytrain: Surasak
- Bangkok by skytrain: Thong Lor
Sign up for Travelfish Burp!
Our weekly wrap on Southeast Asian travel.
Click here to see a recent newsletter.